Musing on faith

I mentioned in a comment recently that I'd just finished reading Richard Dawkins' book The God Delusion. Religion and faith and lack of faith have been hot topics recently, and I've, naturally, been thinking about religion.

I don't have a clear picture of when I first went to church. The first church I went to was an evangelical outfit. My bestest friend in kindergarten went there, and my family started going there. My mom eventually became church secretary. I vaguely recall Focus On The Family films being shown in the meeting hall, but I also remember learning about the Maccabees and the history of Hanukkah and Passover, and of course socials (hand-cranked ice cream!) I don't remember exactly when we stopped attending there, but it was definitely after I hit my rebellious phase in middle school. There was some sort of shake-up in the church and people liked or disliked the new pastor and tried to get him fired. My mom didn't like that, so we left.

It was church-hopping for a while after that. We went to a Brethren church that was around the corner from our house. We went to a UMC church that wasn't too far and had a youngish congregation. Neither was particularly welcoming. So we wound up at my grandparents' UMC church when I was in 9th grade. (Or maybe the summer before. I don't remember exactly.) I joined the choir and youth group. I was secretary of both for several years, even. I took confirmation class. In 12th grade, I did an Official Bible Study thing -- I've got the pin somewhere.

In 9th grade, socially-awkward and wanting to fit in, I started going to Young Life because all the cool kids did. I went to the Bible study they had. I went on the trips they made.

But it never stuck. I saw hypocrisy in the cool, supposedly-Christian kids. I saw hypocrisy in the leaders. I was lucky to have pastors who were good people, even if I thought the senior pastor was annoying.

I decided around 10th grade that I wasn't Christian. In college, I read books on Wicca and neopaganism, and I tried. I tried to believe.

I would guess that atheism comes naturally to me. I tried religions. I tried calling the gods. They never came.

I've been on mission trips to Kentucky with the UMChurch. "Faith without works is dead." But what of works without faith? What is that?

Share on Facebook

Ironically...

I love arcane rituals. But performing a ritual is not the same as having faith.

Works without faith

is like taking the gods into your own hands. It is the thing that matters most. All the rest is just wishful thinking.

Indeed.

And it might be the only thing that matters.

"Be the change you wish to see in the world." - Gandhi

I don't know what category I fit in

I remember questioning my parents at a very early age about things they believed without question. My first question was why wasn't Christmas on January 1st if Christ's birth was the beginning of a new age. (New Age = their words) Boy, I would love to have a faith conversation with all of you, I still have many questions.

No matter that patriotism is too often the refuge of scoundrels. Dissent, rebellion, and all-around hell-raising remain the true duty of patriots.

Progressive Discussions

Momo

Everybody I know has questions. Well, not everybody. Just the ones with at least average IQs.

Lovex7

Hey Love,

Darn, I missed you. cye I've always known, something familar inside, that God exists. What I question are the things that are written. Bible, Tora, Quaran all with very good rules to live by, but some of the stories and lessons seem to be too human. God is made in our likeness in them...not so Devine.
Is jury duty over?

No matter that patriotism is too often the refuge of scoundrels. Dissent, rebellion, and all-around hell-raising remain the true duty of patriots.

Progressive Discussions

Momo, I think I'm

like you, I have always felt, deep inside, that God exists, but all those people who seem to be so sure they know what "he" thinks, wants, says, etc., I'm not so sure about them. I don't think God is a "he" or a "she," I think God is spirit. I think there must be many acceptable ways to relate to the creator, not just one.

David Kuo worked for the Bush administration in the area of faith-based initiatives, until he became convinced that the administration was using Christians. He wrote the book, Tempting Faith. David Kuo interviewed John Edwards for Beliefnet.org, and you can see the interview here. Apparently he intends to interview all of the candidates, Edwards just happened to be first.

Jim Wallis, the author of God's Politics, is also associated with that website.

Anyway, most of the time I have lots more questions than answers, but it's interesting to compare notes.

It's over.

I have never been through anything like it. We found him not guilty on both counts...first degree murder and felony child abuse. His evil wife did it. It was front page headlines on Tuesday. You wonder while you are going through it what everybody else is thinking. You can't sleep at night (not just me). You can't talk about it to anybody. I'll blog about it some time when I get my head back. I am starting to get calls from other jurors wanting to know what is going on with the defendant....like I am supposed to know. One guy told me today that he admired my spunk. I think that is a nice way of saying I have a big mouth and I am hard headed. Remember when Lou Grant said, "I hate spunk"? Maybe you aren't old enough. I'm almost feeling normal today. I wondered if I ever would. Isn't it strange how you can't wait for something to be over and when it finally is, you miss the people you have been with for so long?

Lovex7

I've been on a long religious/spiritual journey

and I'd be a fool to think it was over.

I was born into a Presbyterian household. My parents were very involved in the church, which was very "mainstream", and was actually a good place for me to be. My parents always encouraged questions - which explains a lot about my personality.

In high school, I got involved in Campus Life. I can't find a link to them now, but they are/were the same and Young Life, and I was ripe for it - really looking for something to believe in, and they handed it to me. I did have spiritual experiences (no speaking in tongues or anything), and they were real. But as time went on, the strict doctrine and lack of tolerance drove me away.

I am an avid reader, and by some miracle or act of grace in the universe, I wound up managing bookstores from 1983 to 1998. Trust me - that
alone is enough to make me believe that there is some benevolence in the universe. I had at my fingertips all of the works of religion, spirituality, philosophy, and ethics that I cared to read, and care to I did.

C.Diane, I too was drawn to neopaganism and wicca because of what I thought was a unique view of the divine as being feminine as well as masculine. After growing up hearing all about Father God, that was a real comfort for me, especially because I was in the middle of leaving an abusive marriage and was not especially trusting of any one, deity or not, who had a penis. Of course, I know now that there are many religions that claim female deities.

I really can't put a name on my beliefs at this point. I tend to agree with Chartreuse Dog - the Divine is Spirit (I hate to go there, but geek that I am will have to go with The Force ala Star Wars.)

This will sound way earthmother crunchy - but to me there is nothing more sacred than the earth we walk on and the other beings (animals, plants, people) we share it with. The easiest way to put my thoughts on this into language is to say that my hands are "god's" hands, and when I reach out to help with those hands, I am helping "god". (OK, that really did sound crunchy - pass the granola.)

Christians say - That which you did for these, the least of these my brothers, you also did for me. I see similar threads run through all religions that I know of, although I'm not familiar enough with other religions to quote or paraphrase any maxims or verses.

As to whether there's any thing or any One out there - I think there is. But I don't think it matters whether you believe it or not. I think what you do matters, who you are matters, and that you have to walk your journey.

Anyway - just my .05 (adjusted for verboseness and inflation.)

"Be the change you wish to see in the world." - Gandhi

"It's Over" was a response

to Momo who asked if my jury duty was over.

Lovex7

:)

I knew that! My comment that my journey wasn't over wasn't in response to yours!! I'm sorry it looked like that!!

"Be the change you wish to see in the world." - Gandhi

It just doesn't make sense to me.

There's some Big Omnipotent Thing out there that gives a damn what I do and whether I suck up to it with offerings and prayers? If it's so omnipotent, why does it need sucking-up to? Maybe it's got low self-esteem. It's highly illogical.

I don't have that "god-shaped hole." It doesn't bother me, either.

Omnipotent,...

You've hit it right on the noggin-head there Connie. Our Creator is all seeing, all knowing, so why did he set up Eve to fail? Or Cain? He knew before he put the tree of knowledge there that Eve would be tempted by Satan. He knew before Cain and Able asked that his rebuff to Cain would end up with Able's death...so why? The ONLY reason I can come up with is that the Bible was written by man and these are the endings that a man, not a Divine Diety would would conclude.

No matter that patriotism is too often the refuge of scoundrels. Dissent, rebellion, and all-around hell-raising remain the true duty of patriots.

Progressive Discussions

See, that's just it.

I don't think that deity/spirit/god/dess cares one whit about what I do or don't do. I do what I do because it's the right thing. If I seem to contradict myself, it's because I cannot adequately express it. I think both light and dark, life and death have a place in the our world. When they are out of balance, we have serious trouble. Too much life, and the ecosystem cannot keep up with it. Too much dark/evil/death, and we have..well, right now, we have Iraq. We have the OLF. So my purpose is to help restore balance. I don't think that means that if I see too much light/life, I should try killing folks. But it means I should work towards zero population growth, solutions to growth that are sensible and fair to everyone, and other stuff like that. I don't think that "dark" or "death" is always equivalent to bad things. Being present at my father's death, and "midwifing" him through that process was one of the most peaceful and sacred experiences of my life. But death/darkness out of balance - like the horrible wars our esteemed Prez. is fighting is what I work against, in every way that I know how. That's what I meant by being "god's hands" - I just think it means that it's my job to be part of the solution, part of the balancing force.

I've heard the "god-shaped hole" thing used a lot. Personally, I don't have that either. I'm not missing a piece, and I wasn't born missing a piece. After going through my Campus Life/Youth for Christ stuff, I can honestly say I was born ok the first time. Thing is, some folks need to be in a structured faith. That's ok, too. If that's what they need to make their lives work, that's fine. It's when they start telling me what I need that messes me up.

Okay. Enough Rambling.

I'm glad you started this conversation.

"Be the change you wish to see in the world." - Gandhi

This is such a warm and welcoming thread.

Thank you, C. Diane for getting the conversation going. Thank you everyone for posting from your hearts. I recognize so much of my own beliefs in your words. I too am convinced that our journey is much much more important than where we are or where we get to.

My first formal religious education came under the tutelage of Fr. Haines at St. Francis Episcopal Church, Rutherfordton, NC.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket
(Bps. Ronald Haines and Jane Holmes Dixon of the Diocese of Washington after being consecrated the second female bishop in the Episcopal Church, from www.episcopalchurch.org)

I am so thankful for that blessing. Confirmation class was about religion, but in Sunday school and from the pulpit Fr. Haines taught the same things I had read in the little red-letter Bible my grandmother had sent me. He talked about Jesus, charity, humility, mercy, justice, tolerance, grace, forgiveness, good works and care. Though our services were very much high-church (robes, incense, kneeling, standing, chanted Liturgy, weekly Communion) he pretty much left the dogma out of the teaching. I loved going to church.

Later my path ribboned through several levels of independent evangelical fundamentalist churches. The first was very benign. But by the time I got to college, I had seen way too much of cold dogmatic hypocritical absolutism and it turned me away. The grace and humility and goodness of the Jesus I had learned about as a child was gone from those Churches. They had become so caught up in themselves -- practicing their 'gifts' and 'praising God' and being 'righteous' and being 'in the world but not of it' -- that they seemed to totally forget the simple message of the Gospels. I saw little point in church after that until I had kids of my own. We went when we lived in Raleigh. But I couldn't find a church around here where the kids wouldn't be taught intolerant fundamentalist dogmatic b.s. in sunday school. Frankly, I'd rather they were taught nothing than that.

Fr. Haines eventually became a Bishop in DC. He's retired now and works with a congregation somewhere in Pennsylvania. If anyone knows him, tell him that a quiet kid from St. Francis in Rutherfordton says, "Hello." And "Thank you."

"They took all the trees and put them in a tree museum Then they charged the people a dollar 'n a half just to see 'em. Don't it always seem to go that you don't know what you've got till it's gone? They paved paradise and put up a parking lot."