Us vs. Blue Cross in tug o'war over Kay Hagan, who's cut volunteer legs out from under us
Crossposted at DailyKos.com
Just as did millions of other North Carolinians, last week I received the four-color, glossy mailing from Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina that featured a preprinted postcard addressed to Sen. Kay Hagan letting her know how much we Blue Cross Blue Shield subscribers hate the idea of a public option.
As did thousands of others, I marked up the wording on the postcard and took advantage of BCBS's generous offer to pay my postage to let my senator know how fully I support a public health-insurance option.
The mailing from BCBS of N.C. hit people's mailboxes at roughly the same time as notices that the "not-for-profit" insurance company was raising premiums for subscribers -- sometimes raising premiums as much as 40%, even for people who hadn't made any claims in the previous year.
If you've ever had a mailing piece printed, you know how expensive the BCBS of N.C. mailer must have been. It's printed on heavy stock, the photos and colors bleed to the edge, it has a glossy finish, it's printed in full four-color, and it features a perforation for the postcard.
The postcard is postage-prepaid.
One can only imagine how much BCBS spent on production and mailing of this piece, whose sole purpose is to have subscribers send a postcard to one U.S. Senator, Kay Hagan.
Why?
Hagan has been tremendously cagey about her stance on the public option. Previously, she has voiced support for a "community health insurance option" (co-op) and for "community health centers and clinics." Her staff, when asked how Hagan stands on the public option, will say in some form or another, "Sen. Hagan supports the public option as outlined in her proposal for a community health insurance option." Her staff will say they're completely flummoxed, perplexed, and confuzzled at why progressives like many of us here at Daily Kos have criticized the senator as not having come out for a public option, because she certainly does support a public option and has done so since she first supported the community health insurance option.
But support a robust national public option? Tumbleweeds. Crickets.
There have been charges that Hagan is in the pocket of big insurance companies, such as Blue Cross Blue Shield.
But if that's so, why the Bizarro World public relations synchronized mailings of outrageous premium increases teamed with a blitz attack against Kay Hagan?
Here's my guess: Hagan is persuadable. Our efforts to encourage her to support true health-care reform have made an impact. And Blue Cross Blue Shield is bringing out its big, glossy, perforated postcard guns to reduce that impact.
So let's keep the pressure up.
You can turn up the heat on Kay Hagan next Saturday, November 7, at a rally, canvass, and phone bank in downtown Raleigh. Sign up at mybarackobama.com.
The Hope beacon has been lit. Calling all Change Crews to Raleigh. I repeat, all Change Crews to Raleigh!
It has been one year since we made history in North Carolina, when we accomplished the daunting task of turning a Southern state blue for the first time in decades. Echoing our president, "It's time to deliver." Time to deliver on health-care reform.
Former NC for Change campaign staffers are flying out from all over the country to participate for the weekend of Nov 7, so please join us as we celebrate an anniversary and get into action.
Canvass and Phone Bank for Health Care Reform
Kick-Off Rally at 12 Noon
Saturday, November 7
N.C. Organizing for America Headquarters
130 E. Morgan St
Raleigh, NCEveryone is welcome. Come see your old Obama comrades and keep the activism going. Yes, we can reform health care!
In addition to putting the pressure on Hagan to support a robust, nationwide public option, we need to let her know that her waffling on this issue has cut the legs out from under the community campaign volunteers who got her elected.
Her seat's safe for five years, but which of our neighbors are going to believe us when we canvass our neighborhoods to get Richard Burr out of office? After we convinced folks to vote for Hagan, who's going to believe us again?
Hagan has made it very difficult for campaign volunteers who risked hurricanes, 104-degree heat, crotchety people siccing dogs on us, the possibility of physical assault, and threats of arrest while registering voters. It makes a repeat performance as a volunteer a highly unappealing task altogether the next time we're asked to stake our reputations and our well-being on a "moderate."
The Democratic Party needs to let her know this in no uncertain terms.



I'm not sure where Hagan stands, but I suspect BCBS of NC
isn't very sure, either.
We've got to hit this issue hard over the coming days and weeks.
Be sure to let her office know she's done some serious damage to the credibility of Democratic campaign volunteers, too.
Thanks for the cross post
It feels like we're at war sometimes, with the US Mail and the Web operating like artillery. This post is a well placed shot.
my rates went up
I posted over on Daily Kos but re-calculated and realize 1) I need to practice division problems with my fifth grade son more and 2) my rates went up 12%.
I think there is going to be a huge letdown among volunteers who worked so hard, if the Dems don't find their FDR mojo and pass some real reform. This is really the moment, and we need our reps to wake up and realize that this is a big win for the Democratic Party. Do they want to represent us, or just get a cushy lifestyle on our dime and the largesse of the lobbyists?
The letdown
has already hit my checkbook.
Yeah, right
"The beacon of hope has been lit," my ass. More like the stage lighting...
When, exactly, has OFA ever supported a "robust" public option?
Seconded
The Obama campaign arm wants to put pressure on Hagan?
Laughable!
We knew what we were getting with her.
How about putting some pressure on
RahmObama? He's the one who talked about single-payer, but is selling out even the weakest public option.OFA, here's your future, when you don't dance with the one that brung ya.
(It's a link to PPP's evidence of depressed voter turnout among Obama vs. McCain voters).
I was thinking along the same lines...
I never sold Kay as a progressive or liberal when I was volunteering for her in Union County. She never sold herself that way. Of course, a lot of the Dems around here probably think she's too liberal. Go figure.
***************************
I'm baaaaaaack
Certainly she never posited herself as a liberal
or a progressive, yet she did gladly ride the Obama coattails and worked with the progressive organizations Democracy for America and MoveOn in order to take advantage of their people-powered canvassing, phone banking, and other volunteer infrastructures.
Well, we worked for her (no matter how much we'd wanted a more progressive candidate), and now it's time for her to throw us a bone on some reasonable, sensible, moderate health-care policies. Nobody's asking her to ride her white horse into the fray for universal health care, just support for the public insurance option. It's not a Dennis Kucinich-style fantasy dream, it's very practical and shouldn't be such a melodramatic handwringer. Good grief.
Is it selective memory or just willful ignorance?
You're kidding, right? Hagan not only handily won NC by many more votes than Obama, but she was actually declared the winner of NC on election night -- unlike a certain health hypocrite in the White House.
I'm sure you think you're talking about a US Senator here, but the projection away from the White House is just too much. A leader leads.
Yeah, I'd like a support for a public insurance option too...from the White House.
Practicality is...keeping your base happy.
Practicality is...taking advantage broad-based anger --even in the business community --of 20-40% health insurance rate increases and slamming home a real reform package.
Practicality is...using budget reconciliation to get real reform with 50, rather than 60 Senate votes, and dare opponents to dismantle the resulting better, cheaper system in ten years.
If the final version of the 'public option' turns out to be...
the Pelosi-Reid version, which will only cover some low income people, then I'm for a 'No' vote. This seems to be the crooks leading us on, but really getting the "mandatory" coverage for the insurance gang, thus leading to bigger bonuses and higher rates. But we'll see if Sen Wyden, Rockefeller and a handful of others can get some amendments added, which might make it useful for the middle class working people.
I'm with you
In my crystal ball,
Health Care Reform
is going to be
health care reform
and Democrats are going to pay the political price of this failure for years to come.
I agree
and the real killer will be in 2010/2012 when, mark my words, the GOP campaign slogan will be something like:
Ouch.
-b
---
There cannot fail to be more kinds of things, as nature grows further disclosed. - Sir Francis Bacon