Key player in the emergence of modern conservatism, Barry Goldwater offers a nuanced analysis of his interaction with the fledgling gay rights movement and the growing Religious Right. Although his emphasis on personal liberty and limited government prepared the ground for conservative victory, his later backing of gay rights put him into conflict with a sizable portion of his own organization. Examining Goldwater’s initial connection with early religious conservatives, his changing libertarian ideas, and his finally progressive attitude on homosexual rights will help to expose a complex picture inside the conservative terrain.
Conservatism Reexamined
Early Alignment and the Foundation of the Religious Right
Emphasizing individual liberty, limited government, and anti-communism, Goldwater’s conservative mid-20th century platform connected with many who would eventually become members of the Religious Right. Reluctantly conservative voices worried about social change found common cause with his emphasis on traditional American values and hostility to federal expansion. Though it was not successful, his 1964 presidential campaign inspired a conservative base including many with strong religious beliefs, hence laying the groundwork for the later coordinated Religious Right.
The Libertarian Difference and Support for Gay Rights
But Goldwater’s strong libertarianism—that which emphasizes personal autonomy and limited government intervention into personal life—ultimately caused a notable departure from the socially conservative side of the Republican party. Goldwater’s dedication to personal liberty drove him to become a strong advocate as the homosexual rights movement grew momentum. He famously maintained that the government had no right to meddle in the private life of consenting persons and that military service demanded only competency, not sexual orientation.
Conflict Against the Religious Right
Goldwater progressively attacked the growing impact of the Religious Right inside the Republican party by the 1990s. He saw their attempts at moral legislation as a clear conflict with his fundamental conviction in small government and personal liberty. His vocal support of LGBT rights—including the right to serve openly in the military—directly challenged well-known theological Right leaders who regularly denounced homosexuality for theological reasons. Goldwater’s posture resulted from his continuous view against government-mandated personal morality, a philosophy that finally positioned him as a champion of gay rights against the growing tide of social conservatism inside his own political realm.
Overall Thought
Barry Goldwater’s interactions with the Religious Right and homosexual rights indicate a remarkable change inside conservatism. Although his early ideas matched the fledgling Religious Right, his relentless dedication to individual liberty finally made him a staunch supporter of LGBT rights, therefore running afoul of most of the movement he helped birth. Offering a different viewpoint on a pivotal problem in American political history, his posture emphasizes the several and occasionally contradictory ideas within conservatism and the ongoing battle between traditional societal ideals and personal autonomy.
Send us a message—we’re happy to help.